As the previous thread filled up, here is part 2 of the The Unarchiver thread.

• The old thread is here: http://wakaba.c3.cx/sup/kareha.pl/1151796773/
• The homepage is here: http://wakaba.c3.cx/s/apps/unarchiver
• The Google Code page is here: http://code.google.com/p/theunarchiver/

It is much better to post bugs on the bug tracker, rather than in this thread! Anything posted on the bug tracker has much less chance of being forgotten by me!

So, post bugs here: http://code.google.com/p/theunarchiver/issues/list

Also, remember that if you post a bug about a file that is not work, you must also post the file itself, or else there is nothing I can do about it!

In addition, version 0.99 of the command-line utilities has been released. The 0.99 version number signifies that the interface for them should now be the one that will go into 1.0, and which will be stable from 1.0 onwards, but there might still be some tweaks before that. Hopefully nothing will change, though.

Mac OS X version: http://theunarchiver.googlecode.com/files/unar0.99.zip
Windows version: http://theunarchiver.googlecode.com/files/unar0.99_win.zip
Source code: http://theunarchiver.googlecode.com/files/unar0.99_src.zip

• All the file-format-related improvements from post >>34 also apply to this version of unar and lsar.
• The command-line interface has changed drastically. Things have been renamed, moved around and lots of stuff has been added.
• The JSON code output by lsar in JSON mode has also changed.
• unar now has interactive prompts to deal with file collisions and similar things. There are also options to override the prompts.
• unar can now enclose extracted files in subdirectories, much like The Unarchiver. There are various command-line options to control the behavior.
• lsar now has a long format (-l) which displays more information about files.
• The programs now exit with error codes on errors.
• The Windows version no longer needs the OpenSSL dll file, and now only relies on Foundation1.0.dll.
• There is now a separate source code archive for unar and lsar. It contains mostly the same as the The Unarchiver source archive, except for the GUI-specific parts.

Grabbin' it.

Any chance this could open Nero .NRG files?

>>37

Some proprietary ISO formats work. I think .CDI works, but I forget if I tested .NRG. Try dropping one on the icon and seeing if it works. I haven't yet added icons for them, though. I'll try to get that done for the final release.

The simple listing of lsar 0.4.0 (only file path, no filesize, etc.) would be nice to have again. Maybe a --short -s option?

>>39

I guess I could possibly also just revert the standard view to the old format. I added the more elaborate one before implementing -l, so it's a bit redundant now.

hi the unarchiver seems to require a password before it unzips my file but i don't know of any password. please help! thank you!

>>41

Ask whoever made the file.

Here is another alpha release of 3.0:

http://theunarchiver.googlecode.com/files/TheUnarchiver3.0alpha2_64bit.zip

Just a few changes: Support for broken RAR files created by some unidentified archiver, and Japanese, German, Russian and Italian translations.

What I'd really need now are some more translations! I can't seem to get a hold of a lot of the people who did the previous translations, and so I'll need to find some new volunteers. If you'd feel like translating The Unarchiver into your language, please grab the source archive, and then go through the .nib and .strings files in the English.lproj folder, and translate them all, then send me the results.

The source is here: http://theunarchiver.googlecode.com/files/TheUnarchiver3.0alpha2_src.zip

>>35
IMO making xadmaster in a DLL or merging lsar as an option/switch of unar can make the binary size smaller.

I'm trying to create Bash completion specifications for lsar and unar. When it tries to complete an archive name, I'd like it to only offer the names of archive files. Is there a list of extensions that I could use to filter the list of filenames?

>>45

Not really. The Unarchiver doesn't look at extensions much.

You could try to dig out all the extensions listed in the Info.plist file that that the Mac OS X version uses to register for filetypes, maybe.

lsar says this file is corrupted xttp://pastebin.com/VvYp3ir6

>>47
agh, lsar directly from mercurial source.

>>47

Looks like a really new issue, I'll look into it later. For now, try hopping back a few revisions and see if it goes away.

http://apps.bandisoft.com/bandizipx/
doesn't it look like The Unarchiver?

bug report

OSX Lion 10.7.2,The Unarchiver 2.7
Unarchivering x,-,+
and Minimize.
Don't exist to app.

>>50

Hahahah, it sure does. And they're not supplying any source, which is a license violation.

>>52
Sue them for $100,000/day.

I have downloaded the unarchiver for my Mac, however, I can't seem to open the file. It shows this screen and nothing more.

Any suggestions?

Hi. Sorry for the delay.

>>40
Please do. That'd help a lot.

>>49
If I update to the revision 660:db09ff7312a9, just before the tip 661:7006e72e3a01 "Apply Zip64 fix from Greg Seitz", the error disappears.

try to put all of them on or try to up date your computer

The attached file will expand with version 1.6.1 but not 2.7.1

Version 2.7.1 gives error "Could not write to the destination directory."

-Bill

God, BandiZipX even sells in App Store for $1.99 USD!
http://apps.bandisoft.com/bandizipx/

Cyrillic is totally not supported. Every zip and rar has broken filename.

>>59

Please file a bug, with example files and information about what the correct output should be.

Hi,

http://bjfrj.blogspot.com/2012/01/john-talabot-fin-2012.html

the pwd protected rar archive above can not be opened with The Unarchiver. It extracts without problems with Alexander Roshal's unrar 3.60 on the cmd line.

Regards,
Klaus

>>61

It works fine here. What version are you using?

>>55

Should be fixed now, I think.

Time for another alpha version. It's mostly done now, though:

http://theunarchiver.googlecode.com/files/TheUnarchiver3.0alpha3_64bit.zip

However, I am still lacking translations! The Danish, Spanish, French, Korean, Portugese, Swedish and traditional and simplified Chinese translations have not been updated for 3.0. I'd really like to find someone to translate these before the final release, and also any other language which is not supported yet.

(I guess I should just do the Swedish one myself, but I'm not sure I even know Computer Swedish...)

Changes from alpha 2 include:

• Enabled sandboxing. Hopefully this doesn't break anything. This could use some testing!
• Support for old High Sierra CD images.
• Support for LZMA2 in 7z.
• Support for multi-volume StuffIt files.
• Cleaned up the filetypes and added some ISO image formats, like CDI, NRG and MDF.
• Fixed some self-extracting LZH files. (That means Touhou 7.5.)
• Filename encoding handling bugfixes.
• Zip64 fixes.
• Symlinks in zip files were broken.
• Less crashing on supported and unsupported sitx files.
• Fixed junk added to the ends of uncompressed encrypted files in RAR.
• Bugfixes for DiskDoubler, tar and MacBinary.

Well, 3.0 is finally released.

http://itunes.apple.com/app/the-unarchiver/id425424353?mt=12&ls=1
http://theunarchiver.googlecode.com/files/TheUnarchiver3.0.zip

It also has a new site:

http://unarchiver.c3.cx/

A summary of the changes, as listed in the earlier posts:

• Support for WinZip Zipx.
• Support for extracting images and sounds from Flash SWF files.
• Support for various Unix formats, such as ar and deb.
• Support for more CD and DVD image formats, such as MDF, NRG and CDI.
• Better support for Zip64 (large zip files) and extended attributes.
• Better support for 7z (self-extracting files, and LZMA2).
• Better support for some old formats, like LBR, StuffIt and DiskDoubler.
• There is now an option to never create an enclosing folder when extracting an archive.
• The icon is now always shown, even when extracting.
• The Unarchiver is now sandboxed.
• Lots of bugfixes.

Also, it is still lacking translations! It is most definitely time for people to step up and contribute some!

Also, the version of The Unarchiver linked in the last post is the one built for the Mac App Store. It has no support for PPC or older versions of OS X. I hope to get a version built that does have this support, but it's getting a bit complicated, so it will be delayed a little bit.

Similarly, there is no WIndows build for unar.exe and lsar.exe yet. These will also follow shortly.

Oh, also, one change that went unlisted: unar and lsar now have less a less terrible Makefile.

Does it means that if i have already bought the Archive Browser, it is no use for me to install the Unarchiver simultaneously?

Hi!

As a French user, I've seen that unfortunately you no longer support French (among others) on the last version of unarchiver, and you were looking for some volunteers :)

I might try to do it and help you to translate it in French (and maybe in Spanish, but let's deal with the French first), but I was wondering.... how ? How could I "submit" a translation, what is the best way to do it according to your needs, ... ?

Sincerely,
Elendil.

Hi,

I could help too for the French translation. Feel free to contact me !

Hi,

I could help too for the French translation. Feel free to contact me !

>>68

It depends on which interface you prefer. The Unarchiver is simpler.

>>69

Download the the source code from http://theunarchiver.googlecode.com/files/TheUnarchiver3.0_src.zip, then use Xcode to translate all the files in English.lproj, and save them in a fr.lproj directory. You can try copying this into the The Unarchiver along with the others to see if it works.

If you get something working, post it on http://code.google.com/p/theunarchiver/issues/list

Ok, there aren't a lot of strings to translate. I'll do it as I need to relax a little, and post it tonight ;-).

Hi again,

I've opened an issue as you asked, with the French translation file attached (http://code.google.com/p/theunarchiver/issues/detail?id=445&q=french)

hey !WAHa.06x36 & guys. can you help me test this? i'm on lion 10.7.3 and i've read sandboxing is causing problems for some developers and users already.

download isoul from macupdate and decrunch it with v2.7.1. launch isoul and after accepting the quarantine warning (this application was downloaded from safari, blah, blah) it should launch ok.

now try to decrunch it with v3. after accepting the quarantine warning, isoul will just stay bouncing on the dock. clicking on its icon will make it exit without warning. if you try to launch it a second time it will launch ok.

this behavior is happening on other apps and i think that it's caused by sandboxing and a quarantine bug in lion. not sure if it's caused by the unarchiver alone or a combination of lion, safari and the unarchiver (i haven' tested trying to download with another browser). can someone try to reproduce it? thanks.

isoul (direct link from macupdate)
http://www.macupdate.com/download/33320/iSoul%200.5.0.b1.zip

sources about sandboxing and qurantine issues:
http://reviews.cnet.com/8301-13727_7-57374676-263/workarounds-for-quarantine-bug-in-os-x-lion/
http://stackoverflow.com/questions/9544874/how-can-i-stop-my-app-from-setting-the-quarantine-bit

The extract from SWF feature is great, I'd love to have the same for PDF files:

• extract the text into a single txt file
• extract the vectors into a raw post script file per page
• extract the images into png or jpeg files depending on the type

>>75

I've noticed similar problems with other apps, and if you extract shell scripts they will not run at all from the Terminal.

I don't think this is technically a bug in The Unarchiver, more an unintended consequence of some OS X features. It should perhaps be reported to Apple.

Also, does Archive Utility do the same thing or not?

you're right it's apple's fault but caused by sandboxing. many people complaining about the shell scripts (also editing with textedit will screw them up but textwrangler and bbedit won't).

both the unarchiver 2.7.1 and archive utility (sandboxed?) work fine.
i guess it's a matter of waiting for the next major os x update (10.7.3 didn't fix it) or mountain lion.

thanks man and best to you.

If you or anybody else find any information about how to work around this, or if anything else needs to be done to fix it, do post an issue about it on the bug tracker.

according to my link above (stackoverflow.com) the LSFileQuarantineEnabled should be set to FALSE in the application's Info.plist (the unarchiver, in this case) but even so, the bug always sets the quarantine flag on items processed by it. another guy suggested removing the quarantine flag programmatically (in this case, to remove it from the decompressed file) but it can't be done since the app is sandboxed. he also confirms that outside the sandbox, this bug doesn't occur. he filed a bug (i guess with apple) so it's a matter of waiting. i'll post if i have more news on this. keep up.

I had the unarchiver installed via mac app store, there was an update today, which i installed. Now when I try to unzip anything I get the error that the dir has no write permission. Other unzippers work just fine. How can I go back to the older version which had no problems? I checked chown and chmod on the ls -hal of the dirs and files, and they are all in order.

>>81

Due to sandboxing, only some paths are allowed. Currently, this is /Users/ and /Volumes/. What is the full path to the places you are trying to extract files from? I can try to add more in the next version.

In the meanwhile, you can get the old version from the Google Code downloads page.

I look forward to seeing the PPC version. I hope the Archive Browser will be PPC-compatible too.

There is no mention anywhere on the new Unarchiver homepage, the old Unarchiver page, or CNET that this latest version is Intel-only. I had to download to find out it wouldn't work.

>>82

re: your sandboxing...

i get the write permission dialog when I try to unzip to /unShared/incoming/

if I choose [extract elsewhere...] and navigate to /unShared/incoming/ the archive is extracted without issue.

i want the old behavior back, please.

i'll be very pleased to do some translation work for The Unarchiver if i have such a chance. i think i'm qualified to do that interpretation from English to Chinese(Simplified Chinese for Chinese Mainland). Just let me know it how to do it?

>>84

Unfortunately, Apple mandates sandboxing, and it is not possible to tell the sandbox that you want to access all files everywhere, at least not that I have found. So you are unfortunately stuck with it.

If you are really desperate, you can build your own version with the sandbox disabled. Maybe I will try to make the build for older version also not use the sandbox, we'll see what is possible.

>>83

The Archive Browser uses lots of 10.6-only functionality, so it will unfortunately never run on PPC.

>>85

I already had one offer for translation into Chinese, but I haven't received anything back yet for that. So I am not sure how to coordinate things so that you do not do the same work.

>>19
Wait, so you created a completely free implementation of a RAR extractor? One that can handle newer RARs?
Why isn't this big news? Or are there some sort of hush-hush patent issues involved?

>>88

It was pretty big news earlier. FSF announced it as one of their high-priority projects completed.

Since the latest Unarchiver release, when extracting a rar file with multiple parts there is always an error near the end saying the file is corrupted and the whole file contained within the archive is not uncompressed. The files are not corrupted. I tried to extract them using 3 other applications and they all perform well. This sarted happening with the latest 21 March version.

>>86

ok, gotcha, thanx for the info. workaround implemented by creating a /Users/tmp/

sigh.

>>90

I need some actual files that fail if I am going to be able to do anything about it.

The new 3.0 version claims that cannot extract a zip inside my
/Ruse/IdeaProjects folder which is writeable and the version 2.7 can write there easily, I can write there anything from finder, better zip can write there too, but unarchiver 3.0 cannot at all.

Any idea?

>>93

See >>84 and >>86.

How do I uninstall the Unarchiver on my mac osx? Every time I try to open a RAR file it crashes. I can't find it in my applications folder. Please help.
[email protected]

>>95

It is whereever you or the App Store put it. I can not say where that is.

>>65
I can translate this great tool to danish (for free of course). Please contact me if you need me :)
[email protected]

does it support .jar

>>98

Yes. .jar is just .zip renamed.

In the options I have selected: Open the extracted folder on successful extraction.

As far as I can recall, the behavior for the previous 2.x.x versions with this option enabled was to open the enclosing folder with the extracted file/folder already SELECTED/highlighted.

In v3.0, it opens the enclosing folder, but DOES NOT automatically select the extracted file/folder. This can be frustrating when you have many files/folder already in the enclosing folder.

>>100

Yeah, somewhere along the line a bug crept in there. I'll try to get it fixed for 3.2.

Ok, 3.1 has finally been approved, and is now out. Changes are:

• Fix crashing on 10.6.
• Added French and Swedish localizations. More localizations are still needed! If you can, consider submitting one yourself!
• A few other small bugfixes.
• Build for old OSes and PPC available again.

It does not fix any of the sandbox issues, because it is still unclear what can be done. I have started a DTS issue about it with Apple, but they haven't gotten back with a full reply yet. In the meanwhile, if this is causing problems for you, try the legacy version which should not have sandboxing enabled, and report back if it works better! I could really use some feedback on this.

Confirmed, 3.1 (legacy) fixed sandbox issues; I downloaded the same applications that failed under 3.0 and they extracted and launched correctly on 3.1.

Where did you put the PPC version? The Unarchiver 3.1 "legacy" version is Intel.

>>104

Hmm, it's supposed to be PPC too, but maybe it isn't. That's a mistake.

Ok, Xcode is just not building the PPC version even though I have the PPC compiler installed, and selected. Geez. I have no idea what's up with that.

If anyone has any clue how to get this to build right, I'd really appreciate hearing about it.

Hey! I want translate it to dutch! What e-mail can i use to send an e-mail?

>>107

[email protected]

However, I think someone just offered to do that earlier this morning. I haven't heard anything back yet though.

What's the last version that definitely works on a PPC running 10.4.11? Thanks.

>>109

2.7.1 should run, and 3.1 would also run if I could just convince Xcode to compile it. Hopefully soon I will figure it out.

Version 3.1 is still not working outside those "special" folders. I have a folder called /Install where I put all my downloaded stuff and The Unarchiver does not work.

I hate it when a super piece of software stop working when a new version is released... Can you please fix this?

>>111

Get the legacy version. There appears to be no way to request write access to the entire filesystem with the sandbox.

Hey, does The Unarchiver support multi-part RARs for unzipping? Thanks!

>>113

Yes.

So, in the end, I put together an alternate build system using make, so that I could build a version that runs on PPC. It is now released as 3.1.1:

http://theunarchiver.googlecode.com/files/TheUnarchiver3.1.1_legacy.zip

The only change here is the added PPC support. There will not be an update to 3.1.1 for the App Store version, as there are no changes that affects that version.

I'd appreciate some feedback on how well this version works!

Thank you for the PPC version 3.1.1
It is working on a PowerBook G3 Pismo 500MHz.
Tested with a .7z, and some very old .sit and .hqx
-Bill

Yes, thanks for the extra effort to make the PPC version.

I tested it on a bunch of archives - no problems so far.

All right, then I should be set for PPC releases for the forseeable future, since I no longer need to rely on Xcode (just need an old copy of gcc from that).

However, since it's a separate build system, some bugs might creep in if I forget to keep it up to date. If any of you PPC users notice anything amiss in future versions, tell me about it so I can fix it, because it will likely not be that well tested, as I have no access to a PPC machine regularly.

I currently have version 3.1 installed on Mac OS X 10.7.3. There are instances were my compressed far files will give me an error with far file number 17. It only happens with file number 17 for some reason. When I try to uncompress with Keka for example, I get no error and the files in question decompress correctly. Like I said, this is happening on multiple occasions, and the error is always with file number 17.

I meant to say "compressed far files" not "compressed far files".

>>119

I'd need the actual files in order to do anything about it.

This version still throws an error saying the files are corrupted when extracting a file compressed into several rar files. The files are not corrupted since other tools are able to extract the files correctly. I'm really hoping this is solved soon so I can get back to using this great app as my only unarchiving tool :) If I click ok to dismiss the error the extracted file is never complete.

>>123

Again: I need the files in question, or I can do nothing about it.

It's kind of hard to send you 1GB files. All I can say is that this started happening two updates ago.

>>125

Well, then I can't do anything about it.

>>127

What exactly is the problem?

I got the same Problem like some other guys here. I get an error (file is corrupted) when I try to unpack some files. I have no problem to unpack the files with Stufflt Expander.

Problem with:
The.Big.Bang.Theory.S05E13.PROPER.720p.HDTV.x264-ORENJI
The.Big.Bang.Theory.S05E04.720p.HDTV.x264-ORENJI
(Examples)
I guess you can find them somewhere in the net. Releases from other group don't make problems. I guess maybe ORENJI use some special settings.

Thank you for your wonderful tool.
best regards

btw I use The Unarchiver on a MacBook Pro and a MacBook Air, both with Lion 10.7.3

I can't unzip applications and run them using your utility. One high profile example is the Spotify application, which is downloaded as a zip file. I unzipped it using the latest version of The Unarchiver that I downloaded from the App Store, and subsequently could not run it. The application tries to run, and you can see that by an icon opening in the dock and jumping up and down, but when you click on that icon, it disappears. I am running OS X Lion on a MacbookPro5,3 with all updates installed.

I see that other people have mentioned this issue in the past few weeks, and I am asking that you please address this problem, as the Apple Archive Utility does not share this difficulty.

Also, I might add that it is easier for me to uninstall your application and use the Apple Archive Utility, than it is to move everything I need to unzip using your program to the /Users/ or /Volumes/ directories to bypass sandboxing, or to download an out-of-date version of your application through Google Code that will only continue to degrade as more updates are released to OS X Lion. That is a terribly user unfriendly suggestion. You might as well change your icon to duct tape if you're going to suggest users implement your application like that.

Anyway, I don't mean to overtly bash because I really like how minimal this program is designed, and I have used it for many months. That said, I didn't like how you responded to the user reports above, and I hope you can correct this issue before you lose any more of your user base besides just myself.

@128 !Waha.06x36

The issue is that The Unarchiver will not uncompress the .zip file for the specific file (when I posted the comment, the file I attached was for the MacUpdate file "Anti Flashback Trojan" (URL http://www.macupdate.com/app/mac/42571/anti-flashback-trojan); uncompressing it left the application corrupt and unable to launch. Using Apple's Archive Utility (v10.7.1) to uncompress the file resulted in a working application being extracted from the .zip file. I repeated this with The Unarchiver on a separate OS X instance and on my wife's Mac mini and all have the same issue with the same file. I wrote about the issue as well in my review of The Unarchiver on MAS.

>>132

Does it work with the legacy version?

Hello, just adding my experience here..

Recently I've been experiencing strange behaviour - Applications unzipped (using The Unarchiver, although I didn't realize it first) are unable to launch. They will just bounce in the dock. These are files unzipped in one of my User directories, usually Downloads.

Following some searching online, I've finally found out that this happens with The Unarchiver but works with files unzipped with the built-in utility. This happens on either of the v3.1 direct download or Mac App Store versions.

BUT... following msg #133 above, I tried the downloaded v3.1.1 legacy version and everything seems to work fine again. Apps are unzipped using The Unarchiver and they launch!

I'm glad the legacy version exists, but I hope you can fix the main Mac App Store version to work as expected. The cause of the no-launch is not apparent at first, so it'll cause a lot of grief. :)